Exercise II Take Home Messages
There are different "strengths" of the relationship part-of
-
A necessarily is part of B and B necessarily has part A (strongest form)
- A necessarily is part of B and B may or may not have part A
- A may or may not be part of B and B necessarily has part A
-
A may or may not be part of B and B may or may not have part A (weakest form)
GO uses the relationship necessarily is part wherever possible.
Exercise III
Build Your Own Process Ontology
It shows part of the GO process ontology relating to the cell cycle, but the relationships and some of the definitions have been removed. Your task (should you choose to accept it) is to restore the ontology to its former glory with the appropriate definitions and relationships. You may find it useful to read up a little on the cell cycle before starting this exercise.
You can use the definitions you came up with earlier for the undefined terms or formulate some afresh. Do the definitions you use affect the relationships you choose between the terms?
Remember that GO uses part of to mean necessarily is part, i.e. whenever A is present, it is always part of B, but A is not always present.
A few biological facts to throw into the mix:
- In yeast, the nucleus remains intact during mitosis and meiosis, whilst in mammalian cells, the nucleus disassembles and reassembles
- Yeast meiosis produces four sets of DNA inside a single nuclear membrane. The cell then organizes plasma membranes around each set of DNA, forming four new nuclei, and the original nuclear membrane of the cell toughens and becomes part of the protective layer of the cell.
- Tetrahymena have two nuclei which perform chromosome segregation using different mechanisms. One of the nuclei undergoes by mitosis, whilst the other nucleus divides by amitosis, chromosome segregation by simple cleavage of the nucleus. It occurs in the absence of structures (e.g. kinetochores, mitotic spindle) that are typically used to ensure the equal distribution of sister chromatids. The entire cell undergoes cell division, but the individual nuclei performs either mitosis or amitosis.
Some things to think about while you're ontology-building:
- Which stages of the cell cycle occur in all organisms?
- Are all the term strings unambiguous or do some terms need to be renamed?
- Do more terms need to be added to represent this process more clearly?